Showing posts with label Money/Finance. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Money/Finance. Show all posts

Saturday, December 04, 2010

Investing in properties

Last Monday, I had lunch with several colleagues, one of whom is quite interested in property investment. She was telling us about an advertisement in a property magazine she subscribes to, colonial bungalow for sale in Cameron Highland, suitable for boutique hotel, which she said gave her an idea of what to do for retirement (run a boutique hotel). Another colleague shared his friend’s experience of buying a bungalow for RM1.3 million, spent a few hundred thousand ringgit on renovations, and sold the bungalow for RM3 million.

I was quiet most of the time, not having much to contribute, and then confessed, “I still haven’t DARED to invest in a property.” “Why?” she asked. “Because of property bubble, is it?” I just nodded, though that’s not really it. Together, these two claimed, “You should buy! There’s a lot of good properties on Malay reserve. We would have liked to buy, but well, we can’t.”

Coincidently, when I read the paper later that day, I saw a headline in The Star ‘Property Ownership Gap Could Cause Political Instability: PM’. Before I touch more on Amanah Hartanah Bumiputera (AHB) which was the topic of the headline, Let me explain a bit on why I haven’t dared invest in properties, despite the fact that I can afford to do so (for now, at least) and despite having read books about it (for example Azizi Ali) and people sharing tips on tip (for example Mommy Lyna) – for which I’m thankful for. Somehow, just reading about it and never seeing it done before (no one in my family has invested in properties before, not the for-rent type anyway) is not enough to ‘free’ my mindset. Hmm … this is sounding like a lame excuse. But it does make a difference somehow. It’s just like I never needed to ‘think and decide’ whether to breastfeed my children because I see the mothers in my extended family breastfeed their kids all the time.

I think I’m naturally a risk-averse person (actually I’m pretty sure I am). The thought of taking a loan to invest in properties does not appeal to me. Yes, they call it a ‘good loan’ in financial management books, but I still feel that being committed to additional loan is getting me further away from my goal of attaining financial freedom. Yes, they said ‘other people’ will help us service this loan (tenants), but what if I can’t fetch a rent that is enough to cover the monthly installment (negative flow)? What if long periods lapse in between tenants? It would still be fine if I have a fixed income that’s enough to patch those up. But what if I don’t? Between me and my husband, we are a servicing one loan (housing) currently, and even that feels more than enough. I wish I can buy properties on cash basis, haha! Or perhaps what I’m looking for are other type of assets (may not be properties) that are low enough in value such that they can be bought on cash basis, that can still give reasonable continuous income.

Ok, now onto AHB. Pakdi has summarised some points about it pretty well, two of which I’ll highlight here. AHB is syariah-compliant and expected to give 6% return. I haven’t found out whether we would need to pay zakat on the amount we stash away in AHB (should we decide to invest there), but let’s say we do, then our cash is better off in Tabung Haji, which gives about 5% return AFTER zakat (more than 6 minus 2.5=3.5). And then, there’s the other fees involved for transactions, for example when selling the AHB units etc, which are not clear yet at the moment. So, I haven’t decided whether to take up the AHB offer or not. Afterall, many seems to opine that the return could well be above 6%.

Tuesday, November 02, 2010

My motivations to spend less (Part 2)

I’ll pick up immediately from where I left off in Part 1 in my previous post. The second group of motivations for me to spend less is ‘ideals’. The following may sound ‘too perfect’, that’s why I call them ‘ideals’. But they’re something that I aspire towards and TRY to embrace partially, if not totally.

The first is that Islam encourages moderation and not be wasteful (bersederhana dan tidak membazir). If one has excess wealth, it’s better to donate to the needy or spend them in the way of Islam (sedekah dan infak) rather than spend on unnecessary luxury items. Of course, there’s always a delicate balance because it’s not easy to define what is considered as ‘unnecessary’ or ‘luxury’.

Secondly, I want to avoid getting trapped by the consumer lifestyle (consumerism), where marketing and advertising constantly bombard their audience to keep buying and buying, convincing consumers that they really need this and that items. I want to go back to basics and try to have a simple lifestyle. I don’t want to have the urge to always have (buy) the latest, the best, the nicest, the biggest etc.

Thirdly, consuming less means a ‘greener’ lifestyle. The things that we buy and consume take a lot of resources to produce and leave more waste, too.

I believe in:
- Treating/Rewarding oneself and others (occasionally).
- Delayed gratification.
- Wise spending.
- Function over brand or beauty.
- Experiences, not stuffs.

Monday, October 25, 2010

My motivations to spend less

I consider myself as one who’s pretty careful when it comes to spending. I’ve written previously (quite a long time ago actually) about my two hurdles before spending, which I’ll iterate here and add the rest of my internal motivations to spend less. They are more or less split by two categories which are: personal and ideals.

The first under ‘personal’ is that I value the money that I have earned. I’m sure that most, if not all, of us also share this same sentiment. But just to elaborate a bit to explain what this means personally to me. My current fulltime job at the moment is not bad, but all the same, I found myself wishing I’m doing something else almost all the time. The job gives me financial and intellectual satisfaction, but doesn’t fulfill my social, spiritual and emotional needs. So, every hour, every minute I put in this job, counts. That’s why sometimes I value stuffs that I consider buying in terms of my ‘time’. For example, I might think to myself - this handbag would cost me ‘2 working days’, is it worth it? Nah – I’d rather ‘spend’ that 2 days reading and playing with my kids rather than working. This would cost me one hour, that two hours, half day etc … It’s not an entirely rational or functional way to make spending decisions, I know, and it’s only valid on things on ‘want’ basis and never on ‘need’ basis, but it's still a part of the bigger picture, I suppose.

Secondly, I want to save up to build our dream home with as little mortgage as possible (the mortgage turns out not to be so ‘little’ afterall). Enough said.

Thirdly, I am serious about having a career change. Nothing is clear at the moment, but I’m hoping to do something (or more likely, a few things) that I like that is highly flexible (most likely as a self-employed or freelance). I am quite certain that I will not be able to match my current income, in fact I’m only aiming for less than a quarter (and I’m not even talking about the loss of benefits here). I’m not being pessimistic, I’m just being realistic, having explored and evaluated some options. This ‘ambition’ has two impacts; one is that I need to save up as much as I can now while I’m still earning a decent income, to be used for later days. The second is more important - that I cannot inculcate a spending habit or a certain lifestyle that I shall not be able to sustain once I take the big leap (insyaAllah).

Fourthly, and the last under the category ‘personal’, is that, being one who doesn’t enjoy cleaning chores and is rather disorganized, I want to minimize the amount of stuffs that I (we) own and manage in order to minimize maintenance and storage. Less stuffs, less clutter, less cleaning to do, and so on. I used to exclude books in this rule (just buy), but I’m being more picky about books I buy nowadays. If I think I only want to read it once, I’ll try borrowing it first. In fact, I’m thinking of selling some of my books, but that’s a different topics altogether. Back to less stuffs - so, if you step into my home and find it pretty bare, do excuse me. Despite that, my home will still likely to be messy, do excuse me again. Hahaha…

Oh, this turns out to be long enough as a post, so I’ll publish this first and leave the second part for the ‘ideals’ as Part Two for later. But even now, you must be thinking what a stingy person I am, wouldn't you? Hahaha... I hope I'm still able to find a good balance. Semoga Allah memelihara saya daripada bersikap kikir dan kedekut..

Thursday, January 28, 2010

Home loan: Other things to consider

In previous posts, I considered the loan amount, how much should we commit ourselves to if we do have some cash for the downpayment, and decided that we are clear that our aim to minimize the size of debt. And then I considered between a fixed and floating rate package, and decided to pick the floating one, given the current offers by the banks for now (in different circumstance, decision might differ).

What are the other things to consider?

Some banks offer a choice between a zero entry package (ZEC) and non-ZEC. Entrty costs includes legal fees, stamp duty, and valuation fees. Entry costs depends on the loan amount, but typically a 200k loan may cost around 4-6k. There’s a difference between free entry cost and entry cost is financed. For the former, the bank really is picking up the bill. For the latter, you’re still paying for the costs, except it’s added inside your loan amount. If a bank offers both options, the profit rate (or interest rate) would typically differ, with the ZEC package having a higher profit rate, typically by 0.2%. You can try to compute how impact would this 0.2% to the monthly installment (for the whole tenure) and compare that to estimate of the entry cost (as the loan officer to estimate). I usually use this calculator to estimate the monthly installment.

Some banks give you option whether to take up MRTA, but some make it compulsory (surprise surprise). MRTA stands for mortgage reducing term assurance (sometimes known as MRTT – mortgage reducing term takaful), which covers the amount of your loan in the event of your demise. MRTA need not be full at 100%, it could also be at 50% of the amount. The amount would depend on your age and the loan tenure (more reason to aim for lower tenure period), and if it’s a joint-loan, and both person would like to get insured then the MRTA would double accordingly. For a single person, say age 30, loan period 20 years, 100% coverage, MRTA is estimated to be about 3-5k. MRTA can usually be added in the loan amount.

Some banks offer flexi facilities with their package. Three examples. Bank A ties up the loan account to a current account, and the interest is computed based on the balance of both accounts. The more amount you have in the current account, the less interest you’d be paying. I’m not sure how much impact this would have to the bottom line, but the bank will surely be happy to have your deposits! Second example, bank B who allows overdraft facility where you can withdraw amount from the loan account when you need the cash, and likewise deposit more into the account to reduce the interest. Third example, bank C have ‘holiday months’, when you can opt to skip November and December installments each year because people typically need more cash these two months. Of course, the number of months remains the same, so the tenure is likely to be longer and following that, the interest amount is also higher.

Some banks offer tiered rates, for example first 3 years BLR-2%, and thereafter BLR-1%. Or first 5 years fixed at 5% and thereafter BLR+1%. In cases such as this, it is likely that they will have an exit penalty clause. If you want to settle (to refinance maybe) before 5 years for example, there will be some penalty involved when they compute the rebates. Well, sometimes even if there appear to be no fixed cost to the bank (for example ZEC or tiered rate), they may still have this exit penalty clause, so it’s best to check.

In other words, there’s quite a lot of options (450 packages, according to Fiscal-Wise, though of course same bank offering different rates for different loan amount is considered as two different package) to choose from, depending on your needs and preferences. A home loan is a big commitment, so do your shopping and surveying well before committing. Good luck!

Thursday, January 21, 2010

Shopping for a home loan

After a week of shopping for a home loan, I now realized that the fixed rate 6% I had used in my earlier calculation to compare the fiscal benefits between reducing the amount loan vs investing that sum instead, is on the high side! Which is good news for people looking for a home loan like us. BLR is low at 5.55% and most banks offer BLR minus packages, some for as low as minus 2.2% (3.35%). After surveying about 6 banks the old-fashioned way (either inquiring in person or by phone), I decided to go online and found a very useful website which is http://www.fiscal-wise.com.my They have 450 packages from 26 banks! I hope these are updated. Of course, we’ll need to call to confirm the details, but these are good starting points.

At first, before doing this survey, we were close to applying for a fixed rate loan with a bank. But now, with these competitive ‘minuses’ being offered, I have to evaluate again. Let’s say the lowest fixed rate we could get is 5.7% and the likely floating package we can get is BLR-1.8% (with a cap of 10.5%). Which is likely to be better for a tenure of 15 years say, given the history of BLR as below? (source):

Year BLR Readjust
2009 6.50%
2008 6.75% 6.50%
2007 6.75%
2006 6.00%
2005 6.00%
2004 6.00%
2003 6.50%
2002 6.50%
2001 6.75%
2000 6.75%
1999 8.00%
1998 10.50% 12.27%
1997 9.25%
1996 8.50%
1995 6.60%
1994 8.25%
1993 9.50%
1992 9.00%
1991 7.50%
1990 7.00%
1989 7.00%

For the floating package to have the equivalent rate to 5.7%, the BLR needs to be at 7.5%. This means that anytime BLR is lower than 7.5%, the floating package is doing better and vice versa. Over the 15 years tenure, BLR has to be less than 7.5% more time than above.

BLR is currently very low at 5.55% but some people predict it’ll go up again in 2010 and 2011 when the economy is doing better. Besides the economic crisis in 1997-1998, the BLR seems to hover mainly between 6% to 7% for the last 10 years. Based on this, I’d say there is higher probability that BLR will be lower than 7.5% longer time than it is above.

However, given that economic crisis may happen in 10 year cycles, so it’s possible that a crisis may happen again during the loan tenure (hopefully not). If BLR shot up (hopefully not), there’s still the cap of 10.5% for the floating package. If this happens, then I’ll probably wish we had taken the fixed package! In conclusion, it’s not a risk-free decision, but given the current situation and data available, I’ll recommend to MHH that we take the one of the floating packages.

But what are the other things to consider? ZEC (zero entry cost) or non-ZEC? What if the rates are better for higher loan amount? What about MRTA? To be continued…

Friday, January 08, 2010

Reduce debt or invest?

We’re in the midst of deciding how much to borrow for a housing loan. On one hand, we want to be debt-free as soon as possible, on the other hand, the economics shows that the cash would be better off being tucked away elsewhere.

Let’s say I need 300k, and I have 100k cash (all figures are examples only!) then the range of loan could be minimum 200k and maximum 300k, bearing in mind that the bank charges different interest rates for different financing margin as well as different loan tenure (but for simplification I’ll use 6% in the illustration below).

100k (which is the difference between min and max) at 6% for 20 years gives monthly installments of RM717, meaning the total payout at the end of the tenure is 717*12*20=RM172,080, meaning the interest alone is 72k.
Note: I use Bank Rakyat calculator

Let’s say I put in this 100k in a modest (low risk, low gain) investment gaining 5% per annum (compounded), never taking anything out, I will get a neat sum of RM271,264 at the end of 20 years, meaning the returns alone is 171k.

But:
300k at 6% for 20 years means monthly installments of RM2,150 (total payout 516k) – note: this will be understated, since interest rate will definitely be higher than 6% for 100% financing at 20 years
200k at 6% for 10 years means monthly installments of RM2,221 (total payout 266.5k)

Reducing the loan amount by one third reduces the loan tenure by half! It’s so tempting. I think if I were to ask a financial consultant, s/he would say use the cash to invest, I think it’s called capitalizing on the equity (which is the property) or something since a property loan is a so-called ‘good debt’, but I also believe that financial freedom means to be debt-free.

But wait. What if, the 2.2k per month are invested Y10 onwards for 10 years? The total return is RM341,621! Wah, this does change the picture.

Let’s look at the total picture:
Option 1: Loan 300k + invest 100k now = 300 – 516 + 271 = net 55 at the end of 20 years.
Option 2: Loan 200k + invest 2.2k/mth after Y10 = 200 – 266.5 + 341.5 = net 275 at the end of 20 years.

Seems like a no-brainer!

This is, of course, assuming that the 2.2k/month freed after the loan tenure is still available, and not needed for other things like children university fees and such, and will be religiously tucked away month after month (discipline needed!).

Of course, Option 1 and 2 are on the extreme side, for illustration purposes. Perhaps choosing something in between could mean a better balance. Afterall, investing early is recommended to make full use of the time compounding effect.

What’s your take on this?

Thursday, December 31, 2009

Financial analysts

I wonder... since a financial or investment analyst performs analysis on financial data of companies in order to recommend investing decisions (to their employer), does it follow then, that he/she would also be a good personal investor? (given that they're good financial analysts) How far would they be able to use the tools and resources available on their job to make a personal investing decisions?

Thursday, May 21, 2009

Expensive cars

Sometime back, I used to ‘whine’ about the expensive cars in Malaysia. But after awhile, I have ‘accepted’ it as a fact of life. But reading Raslan Shariff’s column in the Star last week brought back the ‘emotions’. I reproduce the article here, and click here to go to the origin:

Literally paying to own a car (Raslan Sharif)

A car that of late became a hot topic in the news pages only costs a buyer in the US half what a Malaysian has to fork out.

I’m a big fan of Top Gear. Besides the cool cars, you just have to love the wit of Jeremy Clarkson and Co. They are hilarious. Top Gear is probably the best TV show on cars, and one of the best TV shows on whatever as far as I’m concerned. I have also been buying the magazine since they launched the Malaysian edition some time back. At RM10, it’s cheap, far cheaper than the UK edition. And at that price, it is an unbelievable bargain. You not only get very informative car reviews and interesting features in the magazine, but there are also columns by Clarkson, Richard Hammond and James May (Clarkson’s partners in crime) as well as other writers on the editorial staff to look forward to. From the reviews, columns and features, you learn a lot about the workings of the global auto industry.

When you start to know how cars are made, marketed and sold in other parts of the world, you begin to understand that there are several things that badly need fixing in the local auto sector, primarily because car buyers here are made to literally pay for it. First of all, while Top Gear Malaysia is much cheaper than Top Gear UK, you can’t say the same about car prices here and over there. Take, for example, the new BMW X5. Over here, prices start from slightly less than RM490,000. Over there, it starts from slightly more than £40,000. How much is £40,000 at current exchange rates? About RM220,000.

Let’s take a more down to earth car as an example, say, the Toyota Camry, which can be frequently seen on our streets. It’s a popular car, especially among those who can afford to pay about RM140,000 for a car. In the US, car buyers can get a Camry from about US$19,200. That’s around RM67,700 at today’s rates. The most expensive model in the US, the Camry Hybrid, starts at US$26,150, or about RM92,200.

Why the huge difference between the prices? Why do we need to pay twice the price of what the British and the Americans do for the cars mentioned above? Several factors contribute to Malaysia having some of the highest car prices in the world, and among them are the duties and taxes that the Government levies on cars – whether locally manufactured or assembled or imported. It is a lucrative source of revenue for the Government, as about 500,000 vehicles are sold every year in Malaysia.

More importantly for us, the bulk, if not all, of the cost is generally passed on to Malaysian car buyers.

Now, I understand the need for the Government to generate revenue. After all, there are various public needs that have to be fulfilled. There is also the argument that local car manufacturers need protection before they are ready to compete openly, although I think they have been protected long enough.

But try seeing it from the consumer’s point of view.

Most car buyers pay a small down payment and get a loan to finance the remaining cost of their purchase.The interest-bearing loan pays for not just the actual cost of the car, but for the taxes and duties as well. I know I’ve said this before, but it’s worth mentioning again, especially as there is now talk of doing away with that other bane of car buyers – approved permits (APs) for imported cars.

International Trade and Industry Deputy Minister Datuk Mukhriz Mahathir said that ending the scheme (oh, what a scheme it is) was among the many options being considered to ensure that “any levy or tax should benefit the Government”.
He added that “cost savings, if any, should go to the rakyat”. Although Mukhriz’s mention of taxes benefiting the Government probably puts paid to any hopes that I might harbour of deep cuts in the duties and taxes levied on cars, I’m all for major changes to the AP scheme (better still, end it) if it means the cost savings from doing so “go to the rakyat”.

If this had happened earlier, I probably would have had to pay much, much less for the car I own today. The holder of the AP used to import my car, bought about two years ago, had very little to do with the making, transporting, marketing and selling of the car. And it kind of gets to me pretty badly that part of the loan I took to pay for the car went to the AP holder as payment for what is supposed to pass for “effort”.

At least the Government uses my money to build roads, schools and hospitals. I’m looking forward to Mukhriz’s announcement on the APs, and I have a feeling that it would be one that would put a bit of a smile on the faces of those who sell and buy cars. Maybe, someday, we’ll see a serious reduction in duties and taxes on imported cars, and be able to do more than just drool at the prices people overseas pay for their cars.


In this article, Raslan compared the absolute value of the cars. For example, a Camry in Malaysia costs RM140k, while is US it’s USD19.2 multiplied by exchange rate, say 3.6 becomes about RM69k (car price are referring to article above, I didn’t doublecheck), which is already half. What he didn’t compare, but I think is still relevant to the picture, is income per capita. A fresh grad engineer earns about RM2k per month, while a fresh grad in US also earns about the same, but in USD! So while a Camry costs the Malaysian engineer her 70 months salary, it only costed her US counterpart about 10 months salary. It’s absolutely feasible to buy a brand new Camry in cash (while over here 10-year car loans are norms). This of course, does not take into account the different tax systems, for example, and other things like health and education benefits, maybe. Still. We’re taxed heavily on our cars. Is it fair? Well, gain some, lose some, I suppose. At least, the new DPM recognizes that our income per capita is low and has some suggestions to increase it, at least for certain groups of people. I don’t know much economics, but things like this won’t take two or three years. It’ll take decades. But it’s a start, anyway.

Friday, May 15, 2009

Bank income vs return

The main source of income for banks are from loans, isn’t it? I wonder, when they charge 6-8% (say) per annum for consumer loans, how can Bank Rakyat give 15-20% returns per annum to their members? Or do they charge higher interest/profit rate for commercial loans? Well, credit card uses are charged 15-18% per annum. Do banks have other sources of income? Usually banks use the cash deposited by account holders to give out loans (and the banks would come out with all sorts of promotions to attract people to keep their money with them), and in return depositors gets 1% (or is it less?), or in the case of FD 3%ish. But of course the members of Bank Rakyat are a different case altogether, they are like shareholders, maybe. But still. Well, this is perhaps too simplistic a way of looking at the bank industry, which I don’t know much about, but I can still ‘wonder’, can’t I?

Wednesday, January 28, 2009

Putting away the coins

I once read (or heard) a tip to save money, which is to put away your coins balances. For example, I brought RM5 to lunch and spent only RM4.50. I should keep away the 50 cent instead of putting it back in the wallet to be spent the next day. Sounds petty and small? I disagree. I believe in the adage ‘look after the pennies, and the pounds will look after themselves’ or in our case ‘look after the cents, and the ringgits will look after themselves’.

Since then, I have been putting away my coins, with the help of my two young ones! About once a week, I’ll get them to dunk the coins in their respective Tabung Haji replica. They love it. At first Adik was prone to putting the coins in her mouth, but after several sessions she understood what she was supposed to do with them. Do they think of it as just another ‘shape-sorting/put-in-the-box’ activity? Well, I hope it will instil some ‘mari menabung feel’ for them. Hopefully, they will associate coins/duit with tabung/menyimpan. In any case, the coins saved will go into their education fund :) Sikit sikit lama lama jadi bukit..

Monday, December 22, 2008

Two hurdles before I spend

It’s still the sales season, and this year round it’s branded as Malaysia Savings Sale, a clever approach to entice people to spend at this time of ‘tightening the purse’. I do think that it could indeed be an opportunity to save, provided we purchase the things we need, rather than buying something just because it’s cheaper, something we otherwise won’t. I am guilty of doing this sometimes, but I think I’m still doing okay. There are quite a few things I need to buy now, especially new clothes for the kids, and now would be a good time, but there’s no opportunity to do that yet – December is quite packed! Later, maybe.

What I like about shopping is getting the new things. What I dislike about shopping is parting with my money (duh!), jostling in the crowd, and having to ‘hunt’ for the things in the shopping list. A perfect shopping for me would mean knowing exactly what to buy (a shopping list), where to get them (exact aisle or shelf, if possible), and how much they are. Then it’ll be just a zip zap and back trip. Shopping usually feels like a chore, but I occasionally do enjoy the window shopping and hunting. Rarely, but sometimes.

In general, I think I’m careful about spending (though MHH may beg to differ, hehe). In fact, I think I could be ‘unreasonably’ prudent sometimes (my family members would probably agree with this). Of course, I’m talking about things other than necessities. I don’t think twice about buying food and clothes and diapers. Though, there’s still the question of which food and which clothes etc. There are basically two hurdles before I spend. First, I think about the price of the goods in terms of my time, based on my current salary. Although I quite enjoy (some parts of) my work, I have to be honest and admit that I wouldn’t do it if I’m not paid. So, I sometimes think about work as exchanging my time with money. So, whenever I evaluate the price of something, I’d go like, “One hour of work for a lunch? Hmm – worth it or not?” or “One day of work for a new bag?” Hmm.. work? I’d rather play with my kids. Or read a book. Or cook. For that one hour, one day, one week. Imagine slogging at the office for one week, and then being handed nothing but a (for example) stroller. Worth it, or not? Also, because I value my time, I sometimes don’t mind ‘exchanging money’ for them. I wouldn’t go to a shop which is further in order to save, say 5 ringgit, if it means I would spend more time. I wouldn’t go back and change an item wrongly charged because that needs time too.

The second hurdle is, I think about the price of goods in terms of my dream house. At the moment it’s RM100 per square feet (materials and labour). This is actually the rate some 3 or 4 years back, prices of materials have risen since, but I stick to it because it’s such a round number, easy to compute. “Two nights hotel room would cost me 4 square feet of my dream house. Worth it or not?” The one square foot is easy to imagine, it's almost tangible. The more I save, the faster I can make my dream house come true. Delayed gratification, I think of it.

Don’t get me wrong, I do spend. I do have that occasional holidays, the special lunch or dinner treats, that extra-nice clothes or bag or goods, but they were usually contemplated and thought about, and is rarely compulsive. I guess, because I still harbour the hope and dream of quitting my full-time day job to work from home one day, I consciously try to maintain a moderate lifestyle, so that the downward adjustment wouldn’t be so difficult if and when we were to survive on one income in the future.

Saturday, November 08, 2008

KWSP oh KWSP

I disagree with the move to slash down KWSP contribution from 11% to 8%. It would still be ok with me if this slashing is an option (exception rather than the rule), but then I read in the news that this is automated, and those who doesn’t want to do this would have to fill up form etc (paperwork!) which is a disincentive. This means that more people will save less. Adui.. biar bersusah-susah dahulu, asal bersenang-senang kemudian. Unless, the 3% is diligently channelled to other places for example Tabung Haji.

Sunday, October 19, 2008

Buying gold

I have been wanting to buy a bit of gold as investment for quite some time now, but never really made the effort to. Thanks to Ummu Auni and Cik Yan who had shared some information on this. MHH and I resolved to act around last Ramadhan. But price were climbing up. We chose to wait. With the global financial crisis looming, more people are choosing to invest in gold rather than stocks. This has caused the price of gold to rise.

Last Friday, the price went down by quite a bit, so I wanted to go visit the nearest Maybank branch that offers this facility. I called first, and was told that they have no stock whatsoever. The lady who answered explained that they would have stock whenever someone sold them the coins back, or when there’s enough customer order then they will purchase some more from BNM.

I wanted to ask further on how the ‘customer order’ works. Does this mean that we can’t choose which day to buy? If coins are available when someone sells to them, then there are more chances of the coins being available at a time when price is high, because that’s when people would want to sell. The lady wanted to pass me to an officer, but my boss called me while I was waiting, so I didn’t manage to clarify further. I had earlier thought that it’s not difficult to purchase a coin. But now, it seems like a lot depends on stock availability. I wonder if it’s possible to purchase direct from BNM? But surely a huge organisation which acts more as a regulatory body, wouldn’t offer this kind of small transactions with end customers?

I wonder also about the passbook option. I suppose it doesn’t matter it the branch doesn’t really have the physical gold? One can still ‘buy’ on paper (or passbook, in this case). Perhaps this is one the reasons it’s not an Islamic product? (Not that I know the principles of Islamic banking lah). I had earlier (before raya) went to a Maybank Islamic branch to inquire. The officer said the passbook is not an Islamic product, but the coins are okay. I had asked why, but he wasn’t sure and had to refer to his supervisor/colleague who weren’t around then.

When googling, I had come across this blog, which may contain some useful information and links on investing in gold.

Read what Ustaz Zaharuddin wrote regarding gold passbook recently here.

Thursday, January 18, 2007

The pyramid scheme

What is it? You have probably come across it one way or another. You’ll never see the term ‘pyramid scheme’ anywhere of course. The concept is simple; you pay up a number of people (one each layer), and then you wait for your turn to be paid as your name climbs up the layer. Of course, you’re suppose to ‘sell the idea’ to other people and so on and so forth in order to maximize the number of people who will be paying you at your turn. I’m sure it has been around for quite some time, but the first time I came across it was during primary school (which was about 15 year ago), believe or not! At that time the modus operandi was snail mail asking you to mail one ringgit notes to recipients. Nowadays, more canggih methods are employed; emails and websites are ciculated, online transactions or banking-in are preferred. I saw one describing the scheme as ‘an online business’. But one different version was some photostate copies urging readers to join in order to help the ummah. Complete with dalil Qur’an and hadith on how we are encouraged to help each other. Annoyed ada, nak gelak pun ada.

Why bring it up now? Someone had placed the copies of advertisement/instructions at the office surau rack, meant for the likes of zakat and Tabung Haji forms. Amboih! Those were removed of course, and I took care not to peek at the name listed, lest I’d know who put it there.

Does it really work? Well, the ‘investment’ required is usually quite small, for example RM2 each for 5 people equals RM10 in total. I think that a lot of people would be willing to take this risk because the potential loss is quite small compared to the potential income. And I believe it’s not difficult to ‘break even’, ie to receive at least RM10 back. But to reach the huge number of RM200k or RM500k as advertised? Now that’s pretty tall. Of course you can show the maths: 10 people at each 5 layers means ten to the power of five equals one hundred thousand. Multiplied by RM2 each, yes you can get RM200k. But I think it’s not possible, or rather - it is possible but very improbable, to get one hundred thousand peope to buy-in. Especially if this scheme has been around for ages and most people who are willing to try had already done so.

Is it legal from the Islamic point of view? I’m unfortunately far from qualified to answer this question. I can only ask more questions. But the clear thing is, there is no product or service being transacted. It’s more like hoping for people to ‘donate’ their money to you. So to me, it’s very suspicious. Wallahu'a'lam.

Wednesday, September 20, 2006

Managing personal finance – a survey

Crawling traffic felt less annoying when there’s something engaging on the radio (my default radio is Radio IKIM). Yesterday, it was a Wanita Hari Ini segment by Puan Siti Fatimah binti Abdul Rahman, Fellow Kanan di Pusat Ekonomi dan Kajian Sosial, IKIM. She commented on a survey she conducted among working women (number of sample not specified) on managing personal finances. The survey was short and was based around the following indicators. How would I fare had I been included in her survey?


  • Do you have monthly budgets? 77% said yes. Moi: do draw budgets together with my hubby from time to time, but they were neither structured nor strictly by month. So I guess that’s a no.
  • Do you put away a portion of your income as savings? 64% said yes. Moi: yes.
  • What is the percentage of this savings from your income? 21% said they save 6-10% of their income, while 27% save 11-15%. Moi: it’s difficult to answer because the amount varies from month to month. But this should change next month when I start my Tabung Haji monthly potongan gaji, insyaAllah.
  • Is savings your priority when doing monthly budget? 43% said yes. Moi: based on my answer to previous question, it’s a no as well. Spend first, save whatever’s left, rather than the correct idea to save first, and spend whatever’s left.
  • How much of your income is taken up by debt (monthly instalments)? 81% said they use 20-50% of their income to pay up debts. Moi: also belongs to the 20-50% category.

The survey doesn’t cover much, but I guess it is a starter, and mine says I have a lot to improve on! Managing personal finance is quite an essential skill (kemahiran hidup) and yet it is not in the school syllabus. I remember learning Perdagangan in form three Kemahiran Hidup, but that’s from the viewpoint of a company, which is rather different. Puan Siti Fatimah suggests three things we can do; first is to learn by reading or attending courses. A recommended book to begin with is Cukup Wang, Hati Tenang by Hajjah Rohani Datuk Mohd. Shahrir. I’ve read it; it’s quite good - not elaborate, but comprehensive and simple. I’m sure there are a lot of resources in the net, as well. Second, practise what you’ve learnt. And thirdly, inculcate good financial habits in your children.

Dan juga mereka (yang diredhai Allah itu ialah) yang apabila membelanjakan hartanya, tiadalah melampaui batas dan tiada bakhil kedekut; dan (sebaliknya) perbelanjaan mereka adalah betul sederhana di antara kedua-dua cara (boros dan bakhil) itu. (al-Furqan: 67)

Borrow to invest?
A related topic to managing personal finance is investment, and I am intrigued by the rising numbers of banks offering loans for people to invest in unit trust, specifically ASB. Whilst theoretically this makes sense provided that the returns on the investment exceeds the loan interest, the more practical side of me questions whether it's really worth it or not – the hassle, the commitment. Especially now that the base lending rate has soared to a high 6.75% from 6% within 6 months this year, and who knows how it'll go up or down 10 years down the road? With ASB returns not guaranteed, let’s say 7%, that’s a profit of only 0.25%! Of course the actual calculation is more complicated than that, but that’s sufficient to give me a ‘feel’. Of course, some people choose these borrow-to-invest schemes because it’s a form of ‘forced savings’, but wouldn't potongan gaji work as well? On the other hand, we see articles in the newspaper about people who rushes to buy other PNB’s products (for example ASW) the moment the counter opens for the new (limited) units being sold. A lot of people voiced dissatisfaction because they couldn’t manage to get their hands on the units. So we have one group of people borrowing money to invest in ASB, and another group that have ample of money but no ASW units to buy. I prefer not to spell out the suggestive implication. (Note: Of course, when talking about loan and investment, we have to consider whether they comply to syariah principles, to put it in a nutshell. But since I'm no expert, I'll refrain from elaborating.)

Friday, August 18, 2006

Nak tambah hutang, kak?

The spot is a favourite for commercial bodies to promote their products. Yesterday, it was the ABC bank. Armed with umbrellas and other goodies as well as the usual leaftlets, promoters aggressively approached passerbys. I was not spared: “Kak, ni kami ada buat promotion kredit kad dan personal loan. Ambiklah kak; raya dah dekat dah ni.” I mechanically (and politely) dismissed him. A few seconds later (slow as always), I felt annoyed when recalling his words: “Raya dah dekat ni.” Do we spend so much when celebrating festivities? Or generally, has the I-want-everything-and-I-want-them-now culture infected us so much that we borrow money we don’t have in order to spend? Some loans are of course necessary and justifiable, like housing loans or education loans, but loans (or credit) to buy television, furniture, or worse – groceries? How do we manage our finances?

Memetik isi kandungan majalah Anis bulan Jun 2006, perbelanjaan kita terbahagi kepada 3 kategori (level) seperti berikut:

  • Keperluan utama (daruriyyah) contohnya rumah, makan minum, pakaian, dan pendidikan anak-anak.
  • Kemudahan (tahsiniyyah) contohnya kenderaan dan telefon bimbit.
  • Keselesaan (kamaliyyah) contohnya perabot, rumah yang besar, dan kenderaan yang mewah.
Selain kebijaksanaan mengenal pasti keperluan (prioritise), keupayaan mengawal nafsu berbelanja juga memerlukan tolakan sifat-sifat mahmudah terutama syukur, qana’ah, redha dan sabar.

Syukur – mensyukuri nikmat dari Allah dan meyakini nikmat rezeki dan amanah daripada Allah maka dimanfaatkan sebaiknya.
Qanaah – puas dengan pemberian Allah.
Redha dan sabar – nampak Allah bila diuji dengan musibah atau kesusahan, lalu berlapang dada.

Ya Allah, aku berlindung denganMu dari ilmu yang tidak bermanfaat, dan hati yang tidak khusyuk, dan doa yang tidak makbul, dan nafsu yang tidak puas-puas.

Later yesterday I saw an advert in a newspaper:
Imagine all the things you could do if you had a little more cash. Now, xxxx Credit offers you personal financing with minimum hassle and friendly customer service. So, you can enjoy an instant solution and instant cash. Ask xxxx how we can make your life better today!

The advertiser meant the last sentence to be interpreted this way: Ask xxxx today how we can make your life better!

But perhaps it should be interpreted this way instead: Ask xxxx how we can make your life better today! (today only better ah, tomorrow and the next 10 years it’ll be worse!)

Monday, June 19, 2006

Mari Menabung

Yesterday, I sat in to listen to a forum titled Nikmat dan Ujian Harta at Darul Fuqaha. Alhamdulillah, mujur diberi kelapangan dan kesempatan untuk diperingatkan. Sekadar petikan ringkas: kita mestilah memastikan sumber rezeki halal dan kita mesti jua meyakini bahawa harta yang kita perolehi itulah rezeki kita (rather than thinking: if I had done so and so, I would have gotten so and so much more). Mengurus pendapatan pula, ada hadis yang menyebut: sebahagiannya untuk perbelanjaan, sebahagian untuk simpanan, dan sebahagian lagi diinfaqkan fi sabilillah (juga ‘menabung’- untuk akhirat).

One of the panel pointed out an interesting fact: Allah tidak menilai infaq kita berdasarkan nilai intrinsik harta tersebut, tetapi nilai relatifnya. For example, A may have donated more than B, but because the money B donated meant more to him (A is more well-off), then it also ‘weighs’ more. Wallahu’alam. This reminds me of a hadis yang menyebut, seseorang itu belum beriman sehingga dia menginginkan untuk saudaranya apa yang diinginkan untuk dirinya sendiri. Rather than donating our ‘unwanted goods’ or ‘leftovers’, we should be ready to depart with things we’d like for ourselves. Masih jauhnya aku… Ya Allah Ya ar-Rahman, jadikanlah aku lebih ringan tangan untuk membantu umat-Mu yang memerlukan.

Friday, June 16, 2006

Ouch!

Recently, forced by circumstances, my husband and I acquired a second car. We wished we didn’t have to, since we are both in agreement that, for something that depreciates rather quickly, cars are very expensive here in Malaysia. With the rising rate of interest for car loans, the recent price slash (though the word ‘slash’ is hardly accurate; ‘nick’ would be more apt!) is rendered almost negligible. And when was the last time you’ve heard of someone buying a car with cash?

So, I can’t help but to be reminded yet again on how high our cost of living is here. And when I say here, I’m comparing Malaysia to the UK, the only other country where I’ve stayed long enough to have a feel about these things. And before you begin dividing or multiplying figures by 6.5, stop and think again – that’s a rather unfair method of comparing cost of living. A more accurate way is to compare earnings against cost of living, because the general rule is: you earn in ringgit, you spend in ringgit. Unless of course, you are one of the lucky few who lives in Malaysia but got paid in US dollars or Euro.

Let’s take a fresh grad salary for instance: in Malaysia it’s RM2k/month (and even then, that’s on the high side, majority make less) and in the UK it’s also about GBP2k/month (and even so, that’s on the low side). I’ll begin with a car, since that’s what triggered my musing anyway. In the UK, a brand-new Mercedes starts from as low as GBP14k! Imagine – if you save up 1k each month (and that’s very possible, provided you haven’t started paying up a heavy mortgage), you’ll be able to buy a Mercedes cash in less than a year! Here? Don’t even dream – even the cheapest Kancil cost RM22k! What about food? A loaf of bread costs 50p (0.025% of 2k) vs RM3 (0.15% of 2k, 6 times more expensive!), a litre of milk costs 60p (0.03%) vs RM4 (0.2%, 7x), a storybook costs GBP7 (0.35%) vs RM30 (1.5%, 4.3x), a litre of petrol costs about GBP1 (0.05%) vs RM2 (0.1%, 2x) and so on and so forth. To be fair, not everything is cheaper in the UK. Human labour and services are especially pricey, hence locally produced good are usually more expensive than imported ones.

But back to where I begin, buying a car here is quite painful. Rarely can one find a reasonable 'affordable' car. Affordable is not anything as long as the installment is lower than one's income (nevermind if the loan is for 10 years and the installment eats up more than half your salary). I define 'affordable' as costing one years' gross income. A bit harsh maybe, but that my gutfeel. Wouldn't paying out 24% of your monthly salary over 5 years sounds better? (assuming 4% interest and minimal downpayment). So, be honest, what car can you afford?

Yet, why the rant? Do I wish to live in the UK where life is easier? No. I agree with the pepatah ‘Hujan batu di negeri sendiri, hujan emas di negeri orang, baik lagi negeri sendiri.’ Why the rant? We are indeed better off than certain other parts of the world for example Palestine, where life is not about getting by but about survival. Truly, I’m ever grateful to Allah for the abundant rezeki He has bestowed. It’s just that I feel annoyed when we are told that we live in one of the cheapest place in the world (yes if you earn in USD or Euro) or that the nation's economics is prosperous (to who?) or that our life is better now than before (at what cost?) or that our buying power has increased (yeah right). In short, don’t take propagandas for granted, especially if it has direct impact on our everyday lives. Awareness and knowledge will make a difference.

But my thoughts has led me to dangerous places – I really do not crave for an easy and comfortable life as much as I crave for Allah’s pleasure. It’s just that – I wish I can quit my job and stay at home to take care of my baby without thinking so much about the financial implications. Ya Allah, jauhkanlah aku daripada bersifat hubbud-dunia…

  © Blogger template 'Minimalist G' by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP